Thursday, September 27, 2012

Design of Basin Collection Troughs (Part 2), by William H. Boyle, P.E.

If the outlet channel has a water depth within it that will be above the critical depth of the collection trough, then a “submerged discharge” condition exists. The forces that would govern this water level in the outlet channel would be based on the condition downstream. The point where the collection trough enters the outlet channel would then have a submerged depth (HL) greater than the critical depth (Hc). To compute the upstream water depth (Ho), the following formula would be used:

Ho= [HL^2+2Q^2/gb^2HL]^1/2   HL = submerged depth in ft.

By the use of the submerged discharge formula, the headloss would be minimized and the additional head required in the project scheme would be eliminated.

The above formulas are based on the momentum theorem and the use of simplifying assumptions. These assumptions are: the kinetic energy of the water falling into the trough does not contribute to longitudinal velocity, level inverts, flow is substantially horizontal in direction, and the water surface curve is approximated by a parabola.

To design the trough, a sufficient freefall should be available at the upstream part of the trough so flooding of the weirs does not occur. Total headloss from basin water surface to the water surface in the outlet channel is therefore computed by adding the difference between Ho and HL + freefall into the basin trough + head on weir. On short runs of troughs, friction could be neglected, but friction should be incorporated when the headloss is extremely critical and the length of run is extensive. 

When a specific headloss (H0 – HL) is required for the basin collection trough, the trial and error method must be used.  This headloss requirement is a result of the outfall condition mentioned above. In many cases this headloss requirement will be the governing factor for the basin trough design. And remember, by increasing the basin trough cross section, the loss of head becomes smaller.

In summary, it is important for the design engineer to determine if the collection trough will have free or submerged discharge, and size it accordingly.